Alignmint vs Planning Center: Accounting + Ministry in One Platform
Planning Center is one of the most beloved tools in church technology. It's excellent at what it does — worship service planning, volunteer scheduling, group management, and online giving. But there's one critical thing it doesn't do: accounting.
If your church uses Planning Center, you still need a separate accounting system. That means two platforms, two logins, two sets of data, and a manual process to connect giving data to your financial reports.
Alignmint takes a different approach: everything in one platform.
What Planning Center Does Well
Let's give credit where it's due. Planning Center excels at:
- Services — Worship service planning with song libraries, team scheduling, and service order management
- People — Member directory with households, custom fields, and communication tools
- Groups — Small group management with sign-ups and attendance
- Giving — Online giving with recurring donations and giving statements
- Registrations — Event registration with custom forms
- Check-Ins — Children's check-in with security labels
Planning Center is modular — you pick the products you need and pay for each separately. This flexibility is appealing, but costs add up quickly.
What Planning Center Doesn't Do
No Accounting
This is the fundamental gap. Planning Center has no general ledger, no chart of accounts, no journal entries, no fund accounting, no balance sheet, no financial statements, and no Form 990 support. When a member gives through Planning Center Giving, that data doesn't flow into any accounting system automatically.
Your church still needs QuickBooks, Aplos, or another accounting platform. And someone has to manually reconcile giving data between Planning Center and your accounting software — every week. See our guide on church accounting software for what to look for.
No Fund Accounting
Planning Center Giving tracks donations by fund designation, but it doesn't provide fund accounting. You can see that $5,000 came in for the building fund, but you can't see the building fund's total balance, generate a fund-level financial statement, or enforce restricted fund rules.
No Volunteer CRM
Planning Center's volunteer features are focused on service scheduling — who's playing guitar this Sunday, who's greeting at the door. It doesn't provide a full volunteer CRM with skills tracking, background check management, hour logging, or a self-service volunteer portal.
No Marketing Tools
Planning Center doesn't include email marketing, SMS campaigns, direct mail, or marketing automation. You'd need Mailchimp, Twilio, or another platform for donor communication beyond basic emails.
The Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Planning Center | Alignmint |
|---|---|---|
| Fund accounting | No | True double-entry |
| General ledger | No | Yes (pre-built chart of accounts) |
| Financial statements | No | Audit-ready |
| Form 990 | No | Yes (worksheet builder) |
| Donation tracking | Yes (giving module) | Yes (every gift type) |
| Tax receipts | Yes | Yes (automatic) |
| Year-end statements | Yes | Yes (one-click) |
| Recurring giving | Yes | Yes |
| Donor portal | Limited | Full self-service |
| Donation page builder | Basic | Drag-and-drop |
| Worship planning | Yes (Services) | No |
| Song library | Yes | No |
| Volunteer scheduling | Service-focused | Full CRM + portal |
| Background checks | No | Status tracking + alerts |
| Digital waivers | No | Yes |
| Event ticketing | Basic (Registrations) | 7 event types + Stripe |
| Check-in | Yes (children's) | Yes (QR + name search) |
| AI assistant | No | Minty AI |
| Email marketing | No | Yes (drag-and-drop) |
| SMS marketing | No | Yes |
| Direct mail | No | Yes (postcards, letters, handwritten cards) |
| Marketing automation | No | Donor Journeys |
| Video fundraising | No | Video Blast |
Pricing Comparison
Planning Center
Planning Center pricing is per-module and scales with church size:
| Module | Small Church | Medium Church | Large Church |
|---|---|---|---|
| People | Free | $49/mo | $99/mo |
| Giving | $0-99/mo | $99/mo | $199/mo |
| Services | $0-49/mo | $99/mo | $199/mo |
| Groups | $0-49/mo | $49/mo | $99/mo |
| Registrations | $0-49/mo | $49/mo | $99/mo |
| Check-Ins | $0-49/mo | $49/mo | $99/mo |
| Total (all modules) | $0-299/mo | $394/mo | $794/mo |
Plus you still need accounting software ($30-200/mo for QuickBooks or $59-99/mo for Aplos).
Alignmint
| Plan | Price | What's Included |
|---|---|---|
| Starter | Free (up to $100K) | Accounting, donations, CRM, volunteers, events, AI |
| Pro | $499/mo (5-year) | Everything + marketing, MintBucks, advanced reporting |
| Enterprise | Custom | Multi-campus, consolidated reporting, dedicated support |
Who Should Choose Planning Center?
- Churches that prioritize worship service planning above all else
- Churches already deeply invested in the Planning Center ecosystem
- Churches that have a separate accounting solution they're happy with
- Churches that don't need marketing tools, fund accounting, or financial reporting in their church management platform
Who Should Choose Alignmint?
- Churches that need accounting and church management in one platform
- Churches tired of reconciling giving data between two systems
- Churches that need real fund accounting with restricted fund tracking
- Churches that want volunteer CRM, event ticketing, and marketing tools included
- Small churches that want a comprehensive free tier
- Churches that want AI-powered insights into their data
Can You Use Both?
Yes. Some churches use Planning Center for worship service planning (its strongest feature) and Alignmint for everything else — accounting, donations, volunteer management, events, and marketing. This gives you the best of both worlds without the accounting gap.
The Bottom Line
Planning Center is excellent worship planning software. Alignmint is excellent church management software with real accounting. They solve different problems. If your church's biggest pain point is Sunday service coordination, Planning Center is hard to beat. If your biggest pain point is financial management, donation tracking, or running your church operations from one platform, Alignmint is the better choice.
Schedule Your Free Setup | Explore Alignmint for Churches.
Related:
- For Churches — Complete Alignmint overview for churches
- Alignmint vs ChurchTrac — Comparison with ChurchTrac
- Best Free Church Accounting Software in 2026 — Full market comparison
Ready to see how Alignmint works for your nonprofit?
Schedule a free walkthrough — we'll set everything up for you.
